Competencies and competency-based HR are definitely ‘hot topics’ in the HR Arena. They became popular more than two decades ago and, somehow, never managed to go out of fashion, unlike other practices and concepts.
In fact, most HR professionals nowadays are almost brainwashed to think in terms of competencies as they’ve become a critical element of modern HR practices. They provide HR professionals, managers, and employees with clarity on key, often ambiguous, HR systems and practices.
Despite their popularity, however, many people often confuse competence, competency, skills, personality, and abilities. In this article, I discuss not only what a competency (and a competency framework) is. I also write about their benefits, drawbacks, applications, and how to go about developing them for your organization.
A History Lesson…
What is a Competency?
Competence versus Competency
Defining the word “competency” as it applies to HR is not easy or as straightforward as it should be. On the one hand, different writers define it differently, and on the second, historically, British versus American usage has been slightly different. Let’s try to untangle that mess now.
The British perspective

Figure 1: The Concept of competency (adapted from Wong, 2020)
Competency is defined as “an underlying characteristic of a person which results in superior performance on the job” 2.
A competency can contain several elements, such as knowledge, skills, personality traits, self-image, or motives. The key is that whatever the components of the competency, they must contribute to effective performance on the job. If they do not lead to superior performance, then, by the above definition, they are not a competent.
For example, influence can be considered a critical competency for a politician. However, it is not a competency for an accounts payable clerk. Even if the clerk possesses the skill of influencing others, it is still not a competency because it is not needed to accomplish the job.
Table 1: Difference between competency and competence (adapted from Wong, 2020) 3.
| Competence | Competency | |
|---|---|---|
| Focus | Results | Person’s Behavior |
| Purpose | Describe the features of the area of work tasks or job outputs | Describe the attributes of a person |
| Components | The various skills and knowledge needed for performing the job | The underlying attributes of a person for superior work performance |
| Measurement | Performance on the job | Behaviors and attitude |
| Orientation | Task | People |
Competence describes what employees can do (i.e., their skill and skill level). For example, one could say “Ahmad is a competent presenter” meaning Ahmad is able to get the job done when presenting. In other words, Ahmad is a skilled presenter.
We can also say that one of the competencies required for a business development role is negotiation skills. I know the word “skill” is right there in “negotiation skills,” but that doesn’t make it a skill. It’s a competency because negotiation skills are a cluster of skills and not a single discrete skill like, for example, listening.
So, what distinguishes a skill from a competency?
Competency versus Skill
Skills are discrete behaviors or actions that are used to accomplish certain things (think of typing for example) whereas competencies are broad, generic, and universal (strategic planning is a good example).
Skills tend to be situational and specific compared to competencies which are transferable from one situation (or job) to another.
Competencies typically break down into multiple ‘skills.’ If you think of negotiation skills, for example, it’s composed of a combination of communication, listening, asking questions, problem analysis, commercial acumen, empathy, and influencing skills.
KSAs and KSAOs
Where does Personality come in?
Personality is evaluated and described in terms of personality traits or personality type. Personality traits (such as cooperative, flexible, and decisive) are formed early in life, and some are inherited.
Traits are, therefore, extremely stable and unlikely to change. Types and traits can be quite similar, but the key differentiator between the two is that types are discrete categories (for example, a person can be either extroverted or introverted).
On the other hand, traits place these characteristics on a continuum (a person has different levels of introversion and extraversion).
Evidence from research and recent developments in the field have led most psychologists today to be proponents of the trait approach. 4
Can personality change?
Competency Frameworks
CIPD defines competency frameworks as “a structure that sets out and defines each individual competency (such as problem-solving or people management) required by individuals working in an organization or part of that organization.
Accordingly, a competency framework (or model) is the complete collection of competencies needed in an organization along with their definitions, descriptions of acceptable or unacceptable behaviors for each competency (called behavioral indicators), as well as how these competencies will be used, whether for talent acquisition; learning and development; performance management; total reward management; or succession planning 5.
In general, these frameworks define what is considered the most effective behavior and serve as a benchmark to assess and manage employee performance 6.
For example, researchers found that diligent work and targeted behavioral exercises can make people more agreeable and less neurotic in 15 weeks.
Additionally, some personality traits change over time so that we become calmer as we grow older, for example.
However, while it is possible to change some traits, it is not easy to do so as these traits tend to be quite deep-rooted and stable.

Figure 2: The benefits of competency models.
Competency frameworks help managers to communicate which behavior is accepted, recognized, and valued for a specific role. They ensure that employees are on the same page regarding what is expected from them.
A competency-based HR function uses competencies to achieve the following objectives:
- Align the HR functions
- Recruit and select the best talent
- Train and develop employees
- Evaluate employee performance
- Identify successors for key positions
- Administer effective reward strategies
- Support organization development activities and initiatives
From a business perspective, competency frameworks are also important because they address several business needs:
- Clarify expectations.
- Recruit the right people.
- Maximize productivity and performance on the job.
- Align employee behaviors and actions to the strategy, mission, and values of the organization.
- Improve business continuity by developing an effective bench of potential leaders.
- Manage the organization’s culture, especially during times of organizational change.
Types of Competencies
There are many ways to classify competencies. One such approach is to distinguish between threshold and differential competencies.
Threshold competencies are the competencies needed for a given job or role, while differential competencies are those that result in superior performance in that role 7.
In HR, we typically don’t bother with threshold competencies since they are generic and usually covered in the Skills, Knowledge, & Abilities section of the job description.
We do, however, spend a lot of time and effort trying to identify the differential competencies for each job and job family since it is these differential competencies that will help us attract, develop, and retain star performers.

Figure 3: The difference between threshold and differential competencies
However, the most common approach to categorizing competencies is to differentiate between core, behavioral, functional, and leadership competencies.
Some people like to call the functional competencies technical, but nowadays, I prefer functional since there is a whole set of digital competencies that are better dealt with under the banner of technical.
Core Competencies
Core competencies (sometimes called universal competencies) are driven by the organization’s mission and values, and they are the instrument, and tool, for organizational culture.
By cascading the organization’s mission and values into specific competencies that apply to everyone in the organization, we can shape, create, and fine-tune the culture to a large extent.
The general rule of thumb is to hire for the core competencies (instead of developing them internally), unless, of course, you are creating a new framework.
In the latter case, you will need to assess all employees against the core competencies and then decide whether to retain those that need development or train them.

Figure 4: The most commonly used types of competencies.
Behavioral Competencies
These are typically the largest set of competencies in any organization, and they include all the ‘soft’ competencies that are needed for the various jobs, functions, and roles.
Behavioral competencies are transferable and apply to different types of jobs, but they could manifest in slightly different ways across organizational levels. Competencies like resilience, agility, problem-solving, and digital savviness are all examples of behavioral competencies.
Functional Competencies
These are competencies that are specific to employees working in a particular functional area.
For example, a marketing professional needs to have competence in marketing research whilst an accountant needs to be able to reconcile payments.
Leadership Competencies
Finally, there are the competencies needed for employees who lead people regardless of their title. A front-line supervisor needs leadership competencies as much as the organization’s CEO, even if the scope is different.
Examples of leadership competencies include building high-performance work teams, visioning, and motivating employees.
What about technical competencies?
The Components of a Competency
Each competency, regardless of its type, needs to have three components:

Figure 5: The components of a well-crafted competency.
Definition
A competency should be clearly defined so that it is relevant and clear to everyone in the organization. Different people define, and understand, common competencies differently, so it’s very important for HR to establish a common understanding of what is meant by each competency.
A good definition of any competency is expressed in behavioral terms and should not have any ambiguous or relative terms.
For the competency of Facilitating Change, for example, an ambiguous definition would be: Helping employees to become more open to change or highly oriented to change. Using words like more or highly is ambiguous; more than what? Does highly mean every week, day, or every hour?
A better definition is to encourage others to identify opportunities for innovative approaches to addressing problems and facilitating the implementation and acceptance of the change within the workplace.
Proficiency Levels
Take any core, behavioral, or leadership competency, and you’ll immediately notice that the same competency is applied by different employees at different organizational levels.
For example, problem-solving is a required competency for both an entry-level Sales Executive as well as the Director of Sales in an organization. However, the types of problems, their scope, and implications that the director deals with are vastly different from those facing the sales executive.
That’s why we break each competency into different proficiency levels, so we can differentiate between how it is used and applied for employees at various stages in their careers.
Instead of numeric leveling (Level 1, Level 2, etc.), many organizations prefer to ‘title’ their levels such as novice, intermediate, and advanced if you use three levels. With functional competencies, you may wish to mirror the titling philosophy of your organization if you’re identifying levels as well.
For example, if your organization uses Programs Analyst and Senior Programs Analyst as job titles, you may wish to break the behavioral indicators along the same lines.
Notice that you do not need to use the same number of levels for all competencies. The rule of thumb is to use the same number of levels within each type of competency. For example, 5 levels for all behavioral competencies and 3 for all functional and leadership competencies.
It is important to remember that proficiency levels are not performance levels.
Proficiency levels are the levels that distinguish the behavioral indicators for various job levels while performance levels are a measure of how well a particular employee is performing.
For example, the sales executive can be at the performance level of “exceeds expectations” for the novice proficiency level in problem-solving.
How many levels do you need?
Behavioral Indicators
Behavioral Indicators are what I call the ‘fun part’ of competency models. They are descriptions of specific behaviors that we can observe and assess. They are the objective evidence of whether the person has or does not have the competency.
Think about the problem-solving competency example I was discussing above. What are some of the behaviors that a good sales executive demonstrates when they are solving problems?
You might say the sales executive will evaluate the pros and cons of possible courses of action to decide on the best approach and you would be right and have just identified a behavioral indicator for Level 1 or 2 problem-solving.
The Director of Sales will probably work to identify the root cause of problems to develop processes and methodologies to eliminate the problem and prevent its recurrence, and that would be a level 4 or 5, problem-solving behavioral indicator.
Some organizations and HR practitioners create both positive and negative behavioral indicators. Positive behavioral indicators are the ones I explained in the above paragraph. Negative indicators, on the other hand, are behaviors that signal that the employee does not have the competency.
In the case of problem-solving, an employee who ignores a problem or does not evaluate the effectiveness of the solution requires further development in problem solving.
I am a champion of creating negative indicators for all competencies. Managers usually review competencies to evaluate the performance of their employees. Having the negative indicators helps remind the manager of instances of negative behavior if they occurred, and they also contrast and balance the positive indicators.
Additionally, they are invaluable for developmental purposes as they highlight the specific areas on which the employee should focus their development efforts.
Conclusion
In summary, competency frameworks provide a structured approach to defining the key competencies needed for effective performance. They help align HR practices like recruitment, performance management, and development.
Competencies consist of definitions, levels of proficiency, and behavioral indicators that make competencies tangible and actionable. Together, these components equip organizations to identify, assess, and develop the competencies essential for achieving their strategic goals.
When done well competency modeling is a powerful tool that brings clarity and consistency to HR systems.
Want to know more? Continue on to Part 2 of this article where I explain the step-by-step approach for developing a viable competency model (or framework) for your organization.
References
- Sanghi, S. (2007). The Handbook of Competency mapping. Understanding, Designing and Implementing Competency Models in Organizations (2nd ed.). Sage Publications.[↩]
- Klemp, J. O. Jr. (1980). Assessment of occupational competence: final report: introduction and overview (Document Number TD/TNC 87.1109). McBer & Co. for the National Institute of Education (DHEW). Link[↩]
- Wong, S. C. (2020). Competency Definitions, Development and Assessment: A Brief Review. International Journal of Academic Research in Progressive Education and Development, 9(3). (Link[↩]
- Cervone, D. and Pervin, L. A. (2019). Personality: Theory and Research (14th ed.). John Wiley & Sons.[↩]
- Armstrong, M. (2014). Human resource management practice (14th ed.). Kogan Page.[↩]
- https://www.cipd.co.uk/knowledge/fundamentals/people/performance/competency-factsheet[↩]
- Kowal, B., Włodarz, D., Brzychczy, E., & Klepka, A. (2022). Analysis of Employees’ Competencies in the Context of Industry 4.0. Energies, 15(19), 7142. DOI[↩]



