Everything you wanted to know about competencies but was afraid to ask – Part 3

Introduction

In the first part of this three-part series, I defined what a competency is, its components, and the types of competencies commonly used in organizations. The second part focused on explaining the process of competency modeling and I also talked about the use of software for competency management.

In this conclusion to the series, I outline a comprehensive strategy for integrating a competency-based framework into your HR practices. This strategy aims to better align the workforce with the organization’s strategic goals, by ensuring that employees possess the necessary competencies to drive success.

I also highlight common pitfalls to avoid, such as a misalignment with the company’s strategy, inadequate data collection, and poor communication of the competency model and I stress the importance of applying competencies throughout all HR systems to boost the strategic role of HR.

Finally, I discuss the potential of AI and machine learning in refining predictive competency modeling. I also discussed emerging technology trends such as Virtual Reality (VR), which can be used as a cutting-edge method for both assessing and nurturing competencies.

Implementing a Competency-Based HR System

After you develop the competency framework, you can develop competency-based HR guides, systems, and processes. Here are some ideas for how you can begin to develop your competency-based HR function.

Talent Acquisition

Redesign your hiring procedure to reflect the competencies. Start by incorporating your new competencies into your Job Descriptions and developing competency-based interview guides.

You can also design assessment centers that include behavioral exercises and psychometric assessments for critical roles based on the competencies identified for these roles.

Learning and Development

From employee training to leadership development, competencies can help you identify the gaps and guide your learning needs analysis process.

They can also help you create and design your learning interventions to develop the necessary competencies for your organization. The behavioral indicators you mapped can serve as the learning outcomes for your L&D efforts and, therefore, ensure alignment with the strategy.

Performance Management

Incorporate the new competencies into your performance appraisal to enable the identification of star performers as well as the employees who need further development.

You can use the new model to develop assessment criteria, and if you use 360° Evaluations, you can link it to the competencies so you can deliver targeted feedback.

Promotions

Linking your competency models to job grades or pay levels facilitates competency-based promotions and ensures that the people who contribute to achieving business goals are in the right place.

Career Development

Competencies can be used to guide the choice of job assignments and support career development activities in line with organizational needs.

Compensation

You can evaluate employees based on your new competency model to determine their eligibility for pay increases.

Retention

Once you’ve identified your talent using competencies, now is the time to put in place strategies to retain them.

Common Mistakes in Competency Modeling

Misalignment

Misalignment of the competency model happens when you don’t link your competencies and behavioral indicators to the overall strategy of the organization. In many cases, this happens when organizations adopt a preexisting competency framework “as is.”

While it is perfectly acceptable to use a published competency framework as a starting point, you will still need to modify it by, for example, adding, refining, or adjusting the definitions, levels, and behavioral indicators.

Remember that a competency framework identifies the critical behaviors for your business to achieve its strategy. Therefore, it is highly unlikely for a generic framework to meet all your needs. In all likelihood, your organizations will need additional competencies not included in the framework.

Additionally, some of the competencies in the generic framework might not be relevant for you, or if they are, the behavioral indicators might need some tweaking.

A generic framework is a good starting point, but it does not mean you can omit any of the steps of the competency modeling exercise. You will still need to complete all the steps, but when using a generic competency framework as a starting point, you do not need to write the definitions and behavioral indicators from scratch for most competencies. You simply “tweak” them to suit your organizational strategy.

Using hasty data collection methods and tools

Effective competency modeling requires the use of rigorous research methodologies and data collection methods. For example, using multiple data collection points (in other words, multiple methods like surveys and interviews and not relying on one method exclusively).

If your organization is large, you should develop criteria for selecting the people who will be interviewed or observed to avoid bias. If you are going to be interviewing people, develop structured interview guides to ensure that you collect all the data you need.

A key point to remember here is that your competency model must be validated to ensure it is fit for purpose. For critical functions and roles, you may wish to benchmark against other organizations or validate your model against those developed by professional associations.

Adopting a narrow focus

Your competency model should support your organization at a strategic level and therefore, you should build future requirements into your final framework.

Research work, industry, and employee trends internationally, regionally, and in your country to identify the key competencies that will allow your company to remain competitive five or even ten years from now.

You can also use scenario planning techniques here to pinpoint the future competencies that your company might need.

Mapping too many competencies

When mapping competencies to the jobs in your organization, remember that you need the critical competencies that distinguish superior performance only.

A person might need numerous competencies to get a particular job done, but only a fraction differentiates average and superior performance.

While there are no hard or fast rules here, most agree that about 12 competencies for each job are enough.

Not communicating the model effectively

Regardless of how sound your model is, people will need to understand and use it effectively to yield the desired results. Attractive and clear visual diagrams go a long way towards achieving this goal so invest some time and effort in designing a good representation of your framework like the ones depicted in the figure below.

Figure 2: An example of visual diagram of a competency model for Sales Management & Leadership (Soruce: ATD – https://www.td.org/atd-world-class-sales-competency-model)

Your visual model doesn’t need to represent the entirety of your competency framework, but it should focus on the core ideas, categories, or elements of your competency model and make it easy for managers and employees to understand it.

Not aligning your HR systems and processes to the competencies

We get the most value from competencies when all HR functions align with them and are “competency-based.”

Using competencies for performance appraisals exclusively, or even appraisals and hiring only, is a waste of opportunities for greater alignment both within the HR function and between HR and the overall strategy.

In fact, many scholars and practitioners argue that the effective use of competency models can contribute to moving the HR function from an operational to a more strategic role.

Leveraging Software for Competency Management

Software solutions can help both facilitate the process of competency modeling and administration and take it to the next level for your organization. Today, there are several providers that incorporate a data-driven approach when identifying and weighing critical competencies.

Newer solutions rely on using performance statistics, skills assessments, and predictive analytics. For example, algorithms analyze this data to identify correlations between high performance and specific competencies. Those competencies are then weighted as critical. Additionally, large datasets of cross-organizational competency benchmarks allow the software to identify “outliers” – competencies your workforce is distinctly high or low in compared to the market so you can weigh unique strengths and gaps across your entire company.

Systems like SAP SuccessFactors, Cornerstone, and SumTotal offer advanced competency modeling capabilities, which include building fully customizable frameworks, accessing competency libraries, and mapping competencies across your HR processes.

Technology can also help you streamline ongoing competency assessment through methods like 360-degree feedback, auto-generated surveys, and AI-powered analysis of written and video responses. Sophisticated algorithms can benchmark competencies and dynamically update models based on new performance insights.

Most of the leading companies offer features like:

  • Competency gap analysis and integrating the competency data into the learning platform to target development.
  • Aligning competency models with career ladders and succession planning.
  • Linking rewards and compensation to proficiency in prioritized competencies.
  • Talent analytics around competency benchmarks and proficiency trends.
  • User-friendly competency dashboards for employees and managers.

When selecting software, focus on how you intend to use it and its ease of customization. Look for features like customizable competency libraries, competency-based assessments, integration with learning and development, and the software’s reporting capabilities. Remember that this is not a decision HR can make on its own, and you do need to work closely with your IT department to ensure that it integrates seamlessly with your current systems.

Here are some of the top software for managing competencies:

SAP SuccessFactors

In my opinion, they are one of the best, if not the best. SAP offers robust competency management and mapping to career development paths, performance management, and learning. The software also integrates machine learning competency analytics into its solution, which can help identify the right competencies to measure.

SAP, like Oracle, is a full-fledged ERP system, and therefore, this is definitely not a decision that will be made by HR alone. It will require heavy involvement from your IT department due to the customization needed, and implementation will require 6-12 months.

Cornerstone

They started as a Learning Management System (LMS), but in 2020, Cornerstone bought Saba, and the result is a versatile “talent experience” platform. Highlights include competency libraries and profiles, competency-based career planning, targeted learning, and competency-focused performance reviews. Cornerstone also offers dynamic competency assessments from multiple sources – self, manager, peer, etc. as well as AI tools and advanced analytics.

Oracle HCM Cloud

Probably one of the most popular ERP solutions, Oracle HCM Cloud is Oracle’s end-to-end human capital management software suite. It provides a unified solution for core HR, talent management, and workforce management. It can help you build your competency model, assess proficiency, map competencies to jobs/roles, and seamlessly connect them to performance management, career development, and learning.

This is another solution that requires extensive customization and implementation. Additionally, Oracle’s HCM allows managers a limited role in directly updating employee competencies in the system and minimal capability for employees to engage with competency profiles and assessments.

SumTotal

SumTotal is a full-suite HR software provider offering a unified talent management platform, including learning, performance, recruitment, and workforce management solutions. They incorporate features like competency management, assessment, mapping competencies to learning paths, and career development planning. However, while this is a good solution for administering your competency model, it may not be the best option for developing it.

The Future of Competency Modeling and Management

We are facing accelerating change and must build workforces with the agility and skills to keep pace. At the same time, new technologies like Artificial Intelligence (AI) and Virtual Reality (VR)  are disrupting traditional approaches to competency modeling.

Companies like Unilever, IBM, Siemens, and Panasonic are leveraging AI to improve recruitment, performance management, and employee retention.

Rather than a reactive approach, competency management is becoming predictive. Advanced analytics identify the skills that will matter most based on data like project trends, job requirements, and macro employment shifts.

Companies are also making competency development more experiential and self-directed through simulations and agile learning pathways. The goal is to build adaptability and critical thinking, not just technical skills.

As the pace of change accelerates, competencies must become our compass guiding workforce transformation.

Organizations that lead the way will reap the agility, innovation, and performance needed to dominate their industry for decades to come.

Here’s how I see the future of competency frameworks.

AI and Machine Learning to Predict and Assess Competencies

Algorithms can analyze workplace behaviors, performance data, and employee traits to identify patterns predictive of success for a given role. This enables more data-driven competency modeling.

For example, by analyzing sales representatives’ call patterns, machine learning can identify the type of behavior that produces more leads. This behavior can then be translated into a weighted competency for sales roles.

While not yet fully implemented, in the very near future, I expect AI algorithms to analyze large volumes of data from performance reviews, projects, psychometric tests, etc., to identify new competencies predictive of success for specific roles. This allows more objective, data-driven model development.

Machine learning will also enable real-time benchmarking of workforce competencies against large datasets from across the industry.

This will help organizations identify proficiency gaps and strengths more quickly. Moreover, based on employees’ existing strengths and weaknesses, AI can recommend optimal development activities to build the desired future competencies at the required proficiency levels.

Virtual Reality (VR) and Simulations

Immersive VR assessments can measure competencies like crisis management, decision-making, and situational judgment in lifelike simulated environments. While this technology is in its infancy now with few companies adopting it. I believe that it is very likely they will become the ‘standard’ assessment approach in the near future.

Imagine, for example, a VR simulation that places a retail management candidate in a realistic confrontational customer exchange to evaluate competencies like composure, de-escalation abilities, and grace under pressure. These simulations offer consistent, standardized insights into competency levels across candidates or employees, which minimizes assessor bias.

Virtual Reality is also an excellent tool for developing competencies and not just assessing them. For example:

  • Immersive Simulations to create lifelike scenarios to safely practice and build competencies related to high-pressure situations, specialized equipment usage, decision-making, etc.
  • AR overlays information and instructions relevant to the competencies needed at the moment to deliver Just-In-Time knowledge.
  • VR coaches provide real-time feedback on competency demonstration during simulations, identifying strengths and areas for improvement.
  • Expensive real-world training will become a thing of the past as competencies can be built remotely in virtual environments.

Integration with Recruiting, Credentialing, and People Analytics

Today, we can integrate our competency model with job board technology and algorithms so we can tailor our recruiting outreach and screening processes to better match the competencies required for specific positions.

Moreover, online credentials such as digital badges can be mapped to competencies dynamically, providing an effective way to showcase proof of skills and knowledge. This can help job seekers stand out in a crowded job market and enable recruiters to better evaluate candidate qualifications.

To manage competencies more effectively, Human Resource Information Systems (HRIS) can incorporate competency libraries to ensure consistent talent management across the organization while providing insights into areas where competency gaps exist.

We can also leverage analytics to gain valuable insights and identify trends, enabling us to make data-driven decisions regarding talent development and retention.

We can even link online assessments (personality, ability, interests, etc.)  to relevant competencies automatically, streamlining the talent screening process.

This approach enables recruiters to quickly identify candidates that match the required competencies and avoid wasting time on unsuitable candidates.

Conclusion

Competencies are an invaluable tool not only for HR professionals but also for management and leadership in most organizations.

While competency modeling is not an easy exercise, it is worth the time and effort for most companies. With a well-crafted competency framework, you can reevaluate your recruiting process so that the shortlisting and selection criteria you use are based on the competencies and behavioral indicators identified for the job.

You can also design competency-based leadership development programs that align with your organization’s strategy since competencies are the KSAOs needed to achieve organizational goals.

A final word: Remember that a competency framework is never ‘done.’ Regardless of how good your competency model is, it should be reviewed, revised, and updated cyclically to remain a valuable tool supporting your organization in achieving its goals.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Drop a Message